After nearly four years of litigation, U.S. District Judge Susan Brnovich declared a mistrial in the Backpage.com matter pending in the District of Arizona. The Judge found that the government repeatedly flouted the Court’s orders by presenting inflammatory testimony not related to charged offenses in an attempt to play to jurors' emotions.

The Court held that the cumulative effect of the inflammatory child sex trafficking references made by prosecutors in opening statements and by its witnesses “is something that [it] can’t overlook and will not overlook.” It said the government “abused [the Court’s] leeway” and unfairly tainted the jury with inflammatory testimony, instead of focusing on the charged crime.

Bienert Katzman Littrell Williams LLP partners Thomas Bienert, Jr. and Whitney Bernstein represent one of the Backpage.com founders. “The government knows that it can’t prove its case against our client,” said Whitney Bernstein, “so it instead tried to manipulate the jury with heartbreaking and horrendous tales of uncharged child sex trafficking untethered to the case.”

Related Insights

May 14, 2024 Case Successes

Motion to Dismiss Secured for High-Profile Client in Alleged Abuse Case

On May 9, 2024, a Utah Court dismissed the case against Bienert Katzman Littrell Williams LLP’s client Katherine Ballard with prejudice under Utah’s newly enacted Uniform Public Expression Protection Act (Utah.Stat. §...
Nov 23, 2023 Case Successes

BKLW wins defense verdict for client accused of conspiring to steal biomedical trade secrets

Bienert Katzman Littrell Williams LLP scored a complete victory at trial for its client Nathan Boulais, who had been accused of violating, and conspiring with others to violate, the federal civil RICO statute based on...
Jun 30, 2023 Case Successes

Larry Flynt’s brother won’t receive a “single penny” in sweeping BKLW victory

Elizabeth Flynt, the widow of media mogul and First Amendment defender Larry Flynt, and Bienert Katzman Littrell Williams LLP client, scored a complete victory in the lawsuit filed against her by Mr. Flynt’s estranged...