Whitney Z. Bernstein won a published decision in the Ninth Circuit reversing her client’s federal conviction for illegally re-entering the United States after deportation. In the process, she established favorable case law for defending criminal immigration cases.

Whitney’s client immigrated to the United States as a lawful permanent resident (“LPR”) when he was just one month old. He lived legally in the United States for most of life until 2008 when he was stripped of his LPR status and ordered deported from the country by an Immigration Judge at a hearing where he was not even present.

Whitney argued that the 2008 removal order violated her client’s due process rights, and that a later “expedited” removal hearing in 2011 proceeding was also unlawful. Because her client’s immigration hearings were fundamentally unfair, she argued, there was no lawful removal upon which the government could predicate an illegal re-entry conviction.

The Ninth Circuit agreed, explaining that “[a] person should not be stripped of the important legal entitlements that come with lawful permanent resident status through a legally erroneous decision that he or she had no meaningful opportunity to contest.” The Court reversed the federal conviction even though Whitney’s client may have been removable on another ground: “[E]ven if the government might have been able to remove him on other grounds through a formal removal proceeding,” the Court reasoned, “his removal on illegitimate grounds is enough to show prejudice.”

Read the published opinion at United States v. Ochoa-Oregel, — F.3d —, 2018 WL 3650801, No. 16-50413 (9th Cir. 2018).

Related Insights

Nov 23, 2023 Case Successes

BKLW Wins Defense Verdict for Client Accused of Conspiring to Steal Biomedical Trade Secrets

Bienert Katzman Littrell Williams LLP scored a complete victory at trial for its client Nathan Boulais, who had been accused of violating, and conspiring with others to violate, the federal civil RICO statute based on...
Jun 30, 2023 Case Successes

Larry Flynt’s Brother Won’t Receive a “Single Penny” in Sweeping BKLW Victory

Elizabeth Flynt, the widow of media mogul and First Amendment defender Larry Flynt, and Bienert Katzman Littrell Williams LLP client, scored a complete victory in the lawsuit filed against her by Mr. Flynt’s estranged...
Jan 06, 2023 Case Successes

All Federal Anti-Kickback Charges Against Pain Management Physician Dismissed

After nearly a year and a half of contested litigation, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of California abruptly moved to dismiss all criminal charges against the firm’s client, a prominent pain...